Tiago EV vs Comet EV What’s the best E-car under 10 Lakh?
H. Karan Kumar
In the rapidly evolving universe of electric vehicles (EVs), two entry-level contenders – Tata Tiago EV and MG Comet EV – have emerged as strong competitors. With recent price cuts, both models are vying for the top spot regarding affordability, features, and performance. But which one offers the best value for money? Let’s dive in and find out!
The recent price slash of the MG Comet EV has brought it into direct competition with some small petrol-powered cars. Starting at Rs. 6.99 lakh (ex-showroom), the Comet EV is now Rs. 1.60 lakh more economical than the Tata Tiago EV, its closest competitor.
Models | Price (ex-showroom) |
MG Comet EV | Rs 6.98 lakh – Rs 8.58 lakh |
Tata Tiago EV | Rs 8.69 lakh – Rs 12.09 lakh |
Dimensional Comparison: Size Matters
Regarding dimensions, the Tata Tiago EV outshines the MG Comet EV. With a length of 3,769mm, width of 1,677mm, height of 1,536mm, and a 2,400mm wheelbase, the Tiago EV is larger than its MG counterpart, which measures 2,974mm in length, 1,505mm in width, 1,631mm tall, and has a 2,010mm wheelbase.
Interiors & Features: Comfort and Technology
The MG Comet EV surpasses the Tata Tiago EV for premium cabin interiors. While the Tiago EV is equipped with a seven-inch touchscreen infotainment system, Android Auto, Apple CarPlay, auto climate control, and a rearview camera, among other features, the Comet EV goes a step further.
| Feature | Tata Tiago EV | MG Comet EV |
|---|---|---|
| Infotainment System | Touchscreen (7-inch or 8.8-inch depending on variant), wired Android Auto & Apple CarPlay | Touchscreen (10.25-inch), wireless Android Auto & Apple CarPlay |
| Connected Car Tech | May vary by variant, potential for remote diagnostics, charging station location finder | Limited Tech. |
| Driver Information System | Digital instrument cluster (basic on lower trims) | Digital instrument cluster |
| Other Smart Features | – Automatic climate control (on all variants) – Cruise control (on higher trims) – Voice commands (limited) | Hill hold assist (not available on Tiago) |
Powertrain Specifications: The Heart of an EV
Both the Tiago and Comet EVs employ a single-motor, front-wheel drive setup. Tata Motors provides two battery options for the Tiago – a 19.2 kWh unit that delivers a 250 km range and a 24 kWh unit offering a 314 km range.
Specification | Comet EV | Tiago EV |
Battery capacity | 17.3 kWh | 19.2 kWh / 24 kWh |
Power | 42 bhp | 60 bhp / 74 bhp |
Torque | 110 Nm | 104 Nm / 114 Nm |
Charging time (AC) | Up to 7 hours | Up to 8.7 hours |
Charging Time: Faster the Better
MG Comet EV can be fully charged in 7 hours, while the Tata Tiago EV takes up to 8.7 hours for a full charge. However, the MG Comet does not support DC fast charging, unlike the Tiago EV, which can be juiced up in just 58 minutes with a DC fast charger.
Buy Comet EV at a discount with Zecat:
Even after giving exciting features Comet EV is far from affordable for most of the Indians and this huge upfront cost of electric vehicles is what slowing down the growth of electric vehicles in India.
With Zecat, forget the worries of higher upfront costs and own an electric vehicle on monthly payments like your Netflix subscription.
Lease an electric vehicle with Zecat and enjoy endless perks like on-demand fast charger installation, EV consultation, accessories support and much more.
Tiago EV vs Comet EV: What do people buy the most?
According to a report by cartoq.com the Tiago EV out-sells the Comet EV by a 5 to 1 ratio. To put that in numbers, where Tata sold 10,695 units in the first quarter of 2023 MG could sell only 2,139 units in the same market. Unlike competitors, the Tiago EV has the best sales numbers among Tata’s own electric car inventory.
One could say that the Tiago EV is winning due to its affordability factor, but if that was the reason, the Comet EV is far cheaper. Which means there are other reasons for its success.
- Weak competition: The Comet EV is a relatively weak contender due to its small structure and low service centre availability.
- Fast Charging: Despite being an affordable electric car segment, the Tiago EV has some premium features like fast charging, which is absent in the Comet EV. (Comet recently got the fast-charging update.)
Price & Verdict: Which EV Steals the Show?
Even after the recent price reduction, there’s a significant price difference between the top models of both EVs. The top-end variant of the MG Comet EV is priced at Rs 8.58 lakh, while the Tata Tiago EV’s highest variant comes at Rs 12.09 lakh (ex-showroom).
While the Tata Tiago EV offers more range and power on paper, the compact size of the MG Comet EV might be more appealing to urban buyers. Both models have their strengths, making it a tough choice for consumers. However, the final decision boils down to individual preferences and specific requirements.
